Vital Football

Latest Sheffield United News

Shaky Blades Edge Past Millers

Rotherham Utd
1 - 2
Sheffield Utd

The Don Valley Arena


Attendance: 6,737


It took a goal late into stoppage time from Ched Evans to spare Sheffield United`s blushes against an impressive Rotherham United team at The Don Valley Arena tonight. In a game that left more questions than answers from a Blades point of view, Chris Porter was on hand to grab an early lead for United goal only for Rotherham`s Alex Revell to turn in a Lewis Graban cross for a deserved Rotherham equaliser. Then with the game seemingly heading towards extra-time, a Ched Evans strike from just outside the box snatched victory for United and put them through into the last eight of the northern section of the competition.

A massive following of four thousand Unitedites made their way across the city to Rotherham`s temporary home and witnessed another uninspiring performance from a strong Blades side. With only four changes being made from the defeat at the hands of Charlton on Saturday, a 4-4-2 formation saw Nick Montgomery return to his natural central midfield spot for Michael Doyle and Richard Cresswell was drafted in to play on the left wing. The Blades also gave starts to youngsters Ryan Flynn on the right wing for former Miller Lee Williamson and Goalkeeper George Long deputised for Steve Simonsen.

After finding their way to their seats (A running track width away from the action) the first eight minutes did little to quell the feeling of annoyance in the Blades fans. From the off the Millers took hold of the game and it would have been hard to judge for the ignorant viewer which team was in the higher league. All the football was being played by the Millers and for much of the early exchanges the Blades were camped in their own half. Rotherham attempted to exploit their pace down the wings as a means to unlock the Blades defence. This almost proved successful when Newey`s deflected cross flew agonisingly wide of the far post.

In retaliation the Blades pumped aimless long balls up to Evans and Porter who were usually two or five steps away from these hopeful punts. It became seemingly clear that the Blades had been asked to take a more direct approach and it also became seemingly clear that this was highly ineffective. However, with the Blades fans growing more restless a long ball (more through luck than judgement) found its way to PORTER who had the strength and pace to take the ball away from his marker and slide it with his left foot through the legs of the onrushing Warrington into the far right corner…. Queue the confidence streaming back to United?

It was in fact Rotherham that seemed to grow through conceding a goal. They once again targeted the flanks as their hope for any success in attak. This was exemplified in the first chance of note on the Blades goal, as former Millwall winger Lewis Grabban used his pace to cut into United`s eighteen yard box his venomous strike produced a good save from United`s second string keeper Long. United`s defence seemed to have started where they left off on Saturday and miscommunications and errors littered the back fours performance as Rotherham grew in confidence.

The Blades through Porter did manage one more noteworthy chance though, but after being sent through with only the goalkeeper to beat the former Oldham man ballooned his effort over. However, it was the Millers that finished the half stronger and if it wasn`t for another solid save from Long United could have gone into the break level.

The second half did create a change in United`s approach, if but a small one, and it was they who came closest to extending their lead. A pinpoint ball from full back Lescinel unlocked the Millers defence and left Evans one on one with the keeper. Nonetheless, for the third time in the last three games Evans` effort cannoned straight back off the woodwork and Rotherham were given a life line.

This produced a reaction from Rotherham and the increasingly influential Grabban was integral to this. After already skilfully creating a chance for teammate Pringle that was crucially blocked by Maguire at the last moment, his assist minutes later for another team mate and bring Rotherham level. Some poor challenges in the United midfield allowed Rotherham to break in numbers and when Taylor found himself in acres of space on the left he put Grabban through behind the Blades defence. Under pressure from an on rushing Long, Grabban calmly squared the ball for REVELL who was left to side foot the ball into an empty net.

The goal did put a greater urgency into the Sheffield United`s play and as a result came a period of sustained pressure. A cross from Flynn fell to Cresswell who inextricably miscontrolled in the six yard box, which was soon followed up by a Mendez Laing curled effort that was impressively tipped wide by Rotherham`s veteran keeper Warrington.

As a result of an injury to the replaced Mendez-Laing six minutes were put up on the fourth official`s board. These were met with groans by Blades fans that could not bear another minute of this tedium never mind six and potentially 30 on top of that. However, with the game annoyingly heading for extra time, Lescinel went on a penetrative run through the middle of the Rotherham team before laying the ball square. EVANS then let the ball run across his body before letting fly with a shot that inevitably hit the post but this time found its way into the back of the net. A sense of relief seemed evident in players and fans alike. The Blades had scraped through an extremely tough tie by the skin of their teeth.


Although there were a few positives to take out of the defeats on Saturday and at Wycombe the week before, I cannot find one to take from tonight`s performance. In the first half we were a shambles from front to back. The defence looked like four strangers playing together with Jean Francois (Don't let it bounce) Lescinel looking more and more Nosworthy-esque in his decision making with every game and Lowton`s positioning and distribution once again awful at best. The midfield was none existent for the most part. Monty was obviously lacking matches, Flynn reminded child playing with his older brother`s mates and McDonald one again floated around the Pitch not looking like he could be bothered. Up front both Porter and Evans seemed to be attempting to out do each other for who could do the best impression of Claude Rains 'The Invisible Man`. The second half showed a slight improvement and as McDonald got more involved more chances were created. In terms of attack I liked Mendez-Laing`s energy but his defensive work leaves a lot to be desired. We did win but we are going to have to play a hell of a lot better if we are to even draw with the pigs on the 16th.

Star Player

George Long- Very very hard decision as none of United's outfield player's can take any plaudits from tonight. Long made a good punch in the early stages of the first half and backed this up with two deent saves later on. His distribution needs work but from the youth matches I saw him in last season and tonight I feel he could have a future at United. If I wasn't obliged to put a United player I would definitely have to say Grabban he was by far and away the best player on the pitch.


On first half performance alone I would have gone for Lescinel. His constant mistakes and poor decision making nearly had disastrous consequences. However, he did improve in the second half and made a great run for the winner. Instead I'm going to have to say Richard Cresswell. He was anonymous for large chunks and at half time couldn't recall him touhing the ball. Then when put up front he had a very unfortunate miss. The ball looped up to him in the six yard box and instead of smashing it in the back of the net like any goalscorer should have done he instead took a heavy touch that allowed the ball to roll into the goalies hands.

Manager Rating

Danny Wilson- Put it this way that performance has done nothing to silence the critics. Unfortunately he could not substitute the whole team, but I do feel he should have brought on Mendez Laing sooner. He looks muh more of a threat than Flynn but seems to be overlooked. He also seemed to encourage a more direct approach earlier on in the match. If you want your team to 'play like Brazil' why not let them practice against so called 'lesser' opposition.

Date:Wednesday October 5 2011
Time: 1:16AM


that was agony. no blades player capable of putting a foot on the ball. two very well taken goals was the difference though ched also hit the bar and missed an easier one a minute after scoring. confused....where has the football gone?
05/10/2011 13:50:00
We could do with Shane Long up front rather than George Long in goal.
05/10/2011 14:15:00
My bad. I did it was very late or early in the morninng when I did this. Have to agree though Bilbo, any signs of the football we have been attempting to play in previous games was none existent. Long ball is not the way to go! Massive improvemennts need to be made before the wednesday game and a new striker seems imperative. Any suggestions?
05/10/2011 15:08:00
I thought you played a lot of long balls last night while the Millers played the better football. Hope you do well for the rest of the comp and the season
05/10/2011 16:27:00
Spot on Herringthorpe. Millers certainly played the better football, but they always looked likely to concede. Despite The Blades ugly football, the game could have been well beyond Rotherhams reach before the equaliser even though United had limited chances. Ched was always dangerous but The Blades complete lack of any control in any department is a real worry. As Bilbo says, where is the confident, ball on the floor game we saw in the first 6 games?
05/10/2011 19:43:00
There are a number of players that worry me right now, sad to say that Mat Lowton is top of that worry list. His awful choice of final ball at Wycombe - twice - cost us the game, his positioning when defending in the last few games has been woeful and like the rest of the back four he looks to be very low on confidence. I know he will come through it because he has talent, lets hope he is better for the oinkers game.
05/10/2011 19:56:00
I suppose progressing to the next round of this silly cup means that the draw for the next round will be be subject to the usual comedy routine on Skys Saturday morning programme. Sums up the whole daft competition really.
05/10/2011 20:03:00
I have to agree glouc Lowton has been extremely dissapointing of what I have seen of hime this season. His distribution is nigh on amateur and for all his energy the quality seems to be lacking. Also his defending and positioning seems to have gone backwards, in the first half Rotherham got a lot of joy down his side. Where is the player that acquited himself so well in games like Forest at home from last season.
05/10/2011 20:31:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Blades
Write For Vital Blades
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Forest MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Brooks0%
Sub - Holmes0%
Sub - Donaldson0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Sheffield United Results (view all)

Sheffield United Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Olly from the MOD3
The Vital Football Members League